Best Pizza in Midtown Atlanta: A Local's Guide

If you're looking for the best pizza in Midtown Atlanta, you've got a lot of choices in a neighborhood packed with restaurants, coffee shops, and quick-service spots. This guide breaks down what actually separates a good slice from a great one, and why Ray's New York Pizza at 26 5th Street NW has become a regular stop for locals, students, and office workers on their lunch break.

What Makes a Pizza the Best in Midtown

Great pizza comes down to a few basics done well: a properly fermented dough, a balanced sauce, real mozzarella, and an oven hot enough to give the crust some char without drying it out. In a neighborhood like Midtown, where people are often grabbing food between classes or meetings, it also has to be fast without cutting corners.

At Ray's, that means hand-tossed New York-style dough, made fresh and baked to order, whether you're ordering a single slice or a full 16-inch pie.

Ray's New York Pizza: A Midtown Staple

Ray's has been serving Midtown Atlanta pizza, calzones, wings, and Mediterranean dishes from its location on 5th Street since 1990. The menu covers a lot of ground beyond the standard cheese and pepperoni: Greek slices, buffalo chicken pizza, BBQ pizza, and a rotating lineup of specialty pies alongside the classics.

Because the location sits close to Georgia Tech and Tech Square, it's built around the rhythm of the neighborhood: quick slices during the day, full pies for dinner, and delivery or pickup for anyone who doesn't have time to sit down.

What to Order If It's Your First Visit

A few easy starting points:

• Cheese Slice or Pepperoni Slice if you just want a quick, classic bite.

• 14" Buffalo Chicken or BBQ Pizza if you want something with more kick.

• Garlic Knots or Mozzarella Sticks as a starter for the table.

• A Calzone if you want something heartier without ordering a whole pie.

The full menu also includes salads, sandwiches, pasta, and a Mediterranean section with hummus, falafel, and kabobs, which makes Ray's an easy pick even when not everyone in the group wants pizza.

Where to Find Ray's

Ray's New York Pizza is located at 26 5th Street NW, Atlanta, GA 30308, open daily from 11am to 10pm. You can call ahead at (404) 888-9911, walk in, or order online for pickup or delivery.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pizza place in Midtown Atlanta? That depends on what you're looking for, but if you want authentic New York-style pizza by the slice or the pie, Ray's New York Pizza on 5th Street NW is one of the most established options in the neighborhood.

Does Ray's New York Pizza deliver in Midtown? Yes. You can order delivery or pickup directly through Ray's online ordering page.

Is Ray's New York Pizza good for groups? Yes. Between whole pies, calzones, wings, and a full Mediterranean menu, it's easy to order a mix that works for a group with different tastes.

What are Ray's hours? Ray's is open every day from 11am to 10pm.

Ready for a Slice?

Hungry? Stop by Ray's New York Pizza in Midtown Atlanta, order online, or contact us about catering for your next event.